In general, new feature development should be done on master.
Bug fixes should not introduce new APIs or break existing APIs, and do not need feature flags.
Features can introduce new APIs, and need feature flags. They should not be applied to the release or beta branches, since SemVer requires bumping the minor version to introduce new features.
Security fixes should not introduce new APIs, but may, if strictly necessary, break existing APIs. Such breakages should be as limited as possible.
Bug Fixes
Urgent Bug Fixes
Urgent bug fixes are bug fixes that need to be applied to the existing
release branch. If possible, they should be made on master and prefixed
with [BUGFIX release]
.
Beta Bug Fixes
Beta bug fixes are bug fixes that need to be applied to the beta branch.
If possible, they should be made on master and tagged with [BUGFIX
beta]
.
Security Fixes
Security fixes need to be applied to the beta branch, the current
release branch, and the previous tag. If possible, they should be made
on master and tagged with [SECURITY]
.
Features
Features must always be wrapped in a feature flag. Tests for the feature must also be wrapped in a feature flag.
Because the build-tools will process feature-flags, flags must use this exact format. We are choosing conditionals rather than a block form because functions change the surrounding scope and may introduce problems with early return.
if (Ember.FEATURES.isEnabled("feature")) {
// implementation
}
Tests will always run with all features on, so make sure that any tests for the feature are passing against the current state of the feature.
Commits
Commits related to a specific feature should include a prefix like
[FEATURE htmlbars]
. This will allow us to quickly identify all commits
for a specific feature in the future.
Features will never be applied to beta or release branches. Once a beta or release branch has been cut, no new features may be added.
If a feature has made it into beta or release, and you make a commit to master that fixes a bug in the feature, treat it like a bug fix as described above.
Feature Naming Conventions
Ember.FEATURES['<packageName>-<feature>'] // if package specific
Ember.FEATURES['container-factory-injections']
Ember.FEATURES['htmlbars']
Builds
The Canary build, which is based off master, will include all features guarded by the conditionals in the original source. This means that users of the canary build can enable whatever features they want by enabling them before creating their Ember.Application.
module.exports = function(environment) {
let ENV = {
EmberENV: {
FEATURES: {
htmlbars: true
}
},
}
}
features.json
The root of the repository will contain a features.json
file, which
contains a list of features that should be enabled for beta or release
builds.
This file is populated when branching, and may not gain additional features after the original branch. It may remove features.
{
"htmlbars": true
}
The build process will remove any features not included in the list as well as conditionals for features in the list.
Travis Testing
For a new PR:
- Travis will test against master with all feature flags on.
- If a commit is tagged with
[BUGFIX beta]
, Travis will also cherry-pick the commit into beta, and run the tests on that branch. If the commit doesn't apply cleanly or the tests fail, the tests will fail. - If a commit is tagged with
[BUGFIX release]
, Travis will also cherry-pick the commit into release, and run the test on that branch. If the commit doesn't apply cleanly or the tests fail, the tests will fail.
For a new commit to master:
- Travis will run the tests as described above.
- If the build passes, Travis will cherry-pick the commits into the appropriate branches.
The idea is that new commits should be submitted as PRs to ensure they apply cleanly, and once the merge button is pressed, Travis will apply them to the right branches.
Go/No-Go Process
Every six weeks, the core team goes through the following process.
Beta Branch
All remaining features on the beta branch are vetted for readiness. If
a feature isn't ready, it is removed from features.json
.
Once this is done, the beta branch is tagged and merged into release.
Master Branch
All features on the master branch are vetted for readiness. In order for a feature to be considered "ready" at this stage, it must be ready as-is with no blockers. Features are a no-go even if they are close and additional work on the beta branch would make it ready.
Because this process happens every six weeks, there will be another opportunity for a feature to make it soon enough.
Once this is done, the master branch is merged into beta. A
features.json
file is added with the features that are ready.
Beta Releases
Every week, we repeat the Go/No-Go process for the features that remain
on the beta branch. Any feature that has become unready is removed from
the features.json
.
Once this is done, a Beta release is tagged and pushed.